« | Home | »

New U.S. Supreme Court Decision Will Increase Real Estate Commissions

By Jim Gillespie | August 13, 2007

As Florida real estate attorney Henry T. Sorensen wrote in his brief dated July 27, 2007, “On June 28, 2007, an atomic bomb went off in the real estate brokerage industry. The question is whether anyone heard it. On that date, the United States Supreme Court rendered an opinion that could profoundly affect the central compensation structure in the real estate industry, specifically the control of commission schedules offered by brokers to the public.”

In his brief Sorensen discussed the recent Supreme Court decision in the case “Leegin Creative Leather Products, Inc. vs. PSKS, Inc.” This is a case involving a manufacturer of leather products and accessories instituting a minimum pricing schedule for its products to maintain minimum retail pricing levels and to also maintain a strong brand image of the company’s products. And the U.S. Supreme Court held that Leegin has the right to do this.

Attorney Sorensen further wrote that “In one of the most significant parts of the opinion, the Supreme Court noted that without imposing the pricing schedule, retailers would be encouraged to discount prices to the point where (at) quality stores, training and marketing simply could not be provided due to the ever lowering margins made on such sales.”

Do you see any parallels here with the downward pressure on commissions these days in the commercial brokerage industry combined with lower profit margins and less money being available for training and marketing?

In his brief Sorensen concluded that this decision will be a blow to brokerage companies that discount their commissions and that it will have far reaching effects by increasing real estate commissions within the industry. And it appears that the U.S. Supreme Court decision may be most relevant to franchised commercial real estate brokerage companies in terms of any minimum standards that may be imposed on franchisees. But it also raises the question of “What if traditional real estate brokerage companies want to impose minimum commission amounts that must be charged on all real estate transactions closed by their own agents?” Does the U.S. Supreme Court decision apply in this situation also? And as always, you need to consult with your own legal counsel to learn the answer to this question and to learn how this recent Supreme Court decision will impact both you and your company.

With all the downward pressure on commissions these days combined with buyers and lessees themselves wanting to cooperate in receiving portions of the commissions from their commercial real estate transactions, any decision that can help brokers to earn and get paid fair commissions on their transactions will be welcomed by brokers all over the country.

The information on this U.S. Supreme Court decision came to me through an article written by Blanche Evans of Realty Times. For the complete text of Sorensen’s brief on the U.S. Supreme Court decision, click here.


Join Me for FREE on my Teleconference Call This Wednesday on
“Becoming a Master at Getting Exclusive Listings”

If you’ve never been a member of my Commercial Real Estate Inner Circle before, you can join me for FREE on my next Inner Circle teleconference call this Wednesday, August 15th, when I’ll be interviewing the following two experts:

Scott Lamontagne of Marcus & Millichap, who’s been one of my one-on-one coaching clients, and in 2006 Scott sold more apartment buildings than any other commercial agent in the state of Texas. His success has led him to flying in a private plane throughout Texas to utilize his time more effectively and close more business as a commercial broker. The subject of my interview with Scott is “Becoming a Master at Getting Exclusive Listings,” and Scott is definitely an agent who has proved that he’s quite excellent in this arena.

My second interview on the call will be with Robert Campbell, author of the book “Timing the Real Estate Market,” who’s going to tell us when to buy, sell, and hold real estate in our own markets. Robert told everyone here in Southern California in August of 2005 to list and sell their homes if they wanted to cash out at the top of the market, and that prediction has proven to be accurate. In addition, Robert will tell us which markets in the U.S. are now in danger of major reversals in value, and which markets are much safer to invest your money in right now, too.

If you’d like to learn how you can join me on this teleconference call for FREE…click here.

Topics: Uncategorized | No Comments »